Bone Lake is one of those films that looks and feels like it's about to go somewhere dark and thrilling but never quite dives all the way in. Directed by Mercedes Bryce Morgan and written by Joshua Friedlander, this indie horror-thriller premiered at Fantastic Fest in 2024 before making its wide release in October 2025. It's stylish, atmospheric, and well-acted, but it also feels a bit too restrained for its own good. The story follows Sage (Maddie Hasson) and Diego (Alex Roe), a couple looking to rekindle their relationship during a romantic escape to the secluded Bone Lake. Their peaceful retreat turns complicated when they're forced to share a lavish mansion with another couple... Will (Marco Pigossi) and Cin (Andra Nechita) whose charm quickly slides into something much more sinister. What begins as a slightly awkward double date turns into a tense mind game where trust, temptation, and truth blur together. The marketing for Bone Lake sells it as an erotic thriller, but aside from the provocative opening scene-which features a moment that will make most men instinctively cross their legs-the "erotic" aspect is surprisingly mild. After that opening, the film shifts gears into something closer to a psychological relationship test than a steamy thriller. The tension simmers but never boils, and while there's a constant sense that something is off, it rarely hits that nerve jangling level you want from a film like this. That's not to say it's a bad movie far from it. Maddie Hasson and Alex Roe give strong, grounded performances, and Andra Nechita and Marco Pigossi bring an unsettling energy that keeps things interesting. Mercedes Bryce Morgan's direction is confident, with moody cinematography that captures both the beauty and unease of isolation. You can feel the influence of films like Speak No Evil and The Rental, where the horror comes more from social discomfort and suspicion than gore or jump scares. Still, Bone Lake feels a bit too safe. The film teases danger, seduction, and psychological warfare, but often pulls back right when it's about to get good. It's an "almost" movie-almost erotic, almost scary, almost profound. What's left is a decent watch that scratches the surface of deeper, darker ideas without ever taking the plunge.

See other user reviews